天职药房 MISSION (HOUGANG) MEDICAL CLINIC

Running vs Walking: Which Is Better for Weight Loss?

Read Time: 9 minute(s)

Contents

Running vs Walking: Many people turn to two of the most accessible forms of exercise when trying to shed unwanted pounds. Both activities have stood the test of time as effective ways to improve cardiovascular health, boost energy levels, and yes, promote weight loss.

Running is often seen as a fast track to calorie burning. It’s an exhilarating exercise that elevates heart rate quickly, requiring the body to expend more energy in a shorter period. This makes it a go-to for those looking to maximize their workout time.

Walking, by contrast, is the gentler giant of cardio workouts. It provides a low-impact alternative that can be just as effective over a longer duration. Its accessibility makes it an ideal choice for nearly anyone, regardless of fitness level.

The relationship between exercise and weight loss is clear-cut: burning more calories than you consume leads to weight loss. Both running and walking can achieve this calorie deficit. However, they do so at different paces and intensities, which can influence your decision depending on what fits best with your lifestyle and physical capabilities.

Running vs Walking: Benefits of Running

A man jogging on a park path surrounded by trees and greenery. Running vs Walking

If you’ve got weight loss goals, running can be a powerful tool in your fitness arsenal. So, what makes running such an effective weight loss strategy?

1. Higher Calorie-Burning Potential

Running is a high-intensity exercise that requires more energy, thus burning more calories compared to lower-intensity exercises like walking. The more calories you burn, the greater your potential weight loss.

2. High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT)

Incorporating HIIT into your running sessions can supercharge your weight loss efforts. This involves alternating between short bursts of intense running and slower recovery periods. Not only do you burn calories during the workout, but the intensity also triggers the “afterburn effect,” where your body continues to burn calories post-exercise.

3. Understanding Metabolic Equivalents (MET)

Metabolic equivalents provide a way to measure the energy cost of physical activity. One MET is the amount of oxygen consumed at rest. Higher-intensity activities like running have higher MET values meaning they burn more calories.

With this knowledge, you can leverage running to optimize your weight loss journey. Remember, consistency is key! While running offers great calorie-burning potential, it won’t translate into weight loss unless combined with a healthy diet and regular exercise routine.

Running vs Walking: Benefits of Walking

A woman jogging in a park on a sunny day.

Walking is not just a mode of transportation; it’s an accessible form of exercise with a plethora of benefits for those aiming to manage their weight. Its long-term sustainability makes it a practical choice for maintaining weight loss progress. Unlike running, walking can be incorporated into daily routines with ease, whether it’s a stroll through the park or choosing the stairs over the elevator.

Key Advantages:

  • Sustainable Habit: Walking can seamlessly integrate into one’s lifestyle, encouraging consistency which is crucial for weight loss.
  • Accessibility: It requires no special equipment and can be done almost anywhere, from city sidewalks to nature trails.

For individuals concerned about joint health or recovering from injuries, walking stands out as a low-impact exercise option. The reduced stress on joints minimizes the risk of injury and makes walking a viable exercise choice for all age groups, including seniors.

Joint-Friendly Benefits:

  • Reduced Impact: Walking imposes less stress on the body compared to high-impact exercises like running.
  • Promotes Recovery: Ideal for those in rehabilitation or with chronic conditions, walking aids in maintaining fitness without exacerbating injuries.

Moderate-intensity activities like brisk walking are recommended by health professionals as part of a balanced approach to weight management. Engaging in regular walking sessions can contribute significantly to creating the necessary calorie deficit for weight loss without overtaxing the body.

Moderate-Intensity Activity:

  • Calorie Burning: Brisk walking elevates the heart rate enough to burn calories effectively.
  • Heart Health: It improves cardiovascular endurance and overall fitness, contributing to better metabolic health.

Walking may not match the swift calorie-burning effects of running but compensates with its feasibility and gentleness on the body – qualities that make it an enduring ally in the journey towards achieving and maintaining a healthy weight.

Calories Burned: Is Running Really Superior?

A woman drying her hair with a towel after a shower.

When it comes to the calories burned during running vs walking, a common question arises – Is running really superior?

Calorie burning potential of running and walking:

Let’s compare the calorie burning of both exercises. On average, running can help eliminate approximately 62 calories per kilometre[1], while walking might burn close to 37-43 calories for the same distance[2]. In this comparison, running evidently takes the lead in terms of pure calorie-burning capacity.

Exercise intensity and the ‘Afterburn’ effect:

But that’s not the whole story. Exercise intensity also plays a massive role in determining how many calories you burn. An intense run could ramp up your metabolism and keep it elevated for hours after you’ve finished exercising, leading to a phenomenon known as ‘afterburn’ or excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC). This means you continue to burn calories even after your run is over.

On the other hand, walking may not lead to a significant ‘afterburn’ effect but can still contribute to weight loss when done consistently and for longer durations.

So, while running might lead in the short-term calorie-burning race, don’t discount the power of a good walk just yet. It’s essential to consider other factors such as sustainability, joint impact, and personal preference when choosing your preferred method of exercise for weight loss. The best exercise is the one that you enjoy and can stick with consistently.

Understanding the Effects of Running and Walking on Weight Loss

Active lady exercising in a green park.

At the core of weight loss is a fundamental principle: to shed pounds, you need to create a calorie deficit. This means burning more calories through physical activity than you consume through your diet. Both running and walking can play a pivotal role in this equation.

Running for Weight Loss

When it comes to running vs walking, each exercise can contribute to weight loss by creating that crucial calorie deficit. Each stride in a run or step in a walk burns calories, which add up over time to contribute towards weight loss.

How Running Helps with Weight Loss

Running, being a high-intensity exercise, can burn substantial calories in a short amount of time. The higher metabolic equivalent (MET) associated with running means more intense energy expenditure. This results in an increased calorie burn, aiding the creation of the calorie deficit.

Walking for Weight Loss

Switching gears to walking, it’s also an effective way to create that calorie deficit but over a longer duration. Walking is sustainable and can be done for long periods, allowing for consistent calorie burn. Even though it might not burn as many calories per minute compared to running, its ability to be maintained longer makes it an excellent choice for weight management.

Consistency is Key

In either scenario, consistency is key. Regular physical activity, whether it’s daily runs or walks, promotes long-term weight management. It’s about making exercise a habit and integrating these activities into your lifestyle for prolonged periods.

Remember that while creating a calorie deficit is essential for weight loss, it’s also necessary to maintain a balanced diet and healthy lifestyle alongside your chosen form of exercise.

Making the Choice: Considerations for Your Fitness Journey

A woman stretching on the grass, enjoying a peaceful moment outdoors.

When deciding on a fitness regimen to pursue weight loss, there are several factors to consider:

1. Exercise Level

Evaluate your current fitness level and choose an activity that matches it. Remember, it’s important to start at a level that is challenging but not overwhelming.

2. Physical Activity Preference

Think about the types of exercises you enjoy doing. This will make it easier for you to stick to your fitness routine in the long run.

3. Potential Impacts on Joint Health

If you have any existing joint issues or concerns about osteoarthritis, it’s essential to choose an exercise that is low-impact and puts minimal stress on your joints.

For beginners or those returning to fitness after a long break, walking and running are two popular options. Here’s a breakdown of each:

Walking

  • Requires no special equipment
  • Easily adaptable to any fitness level
  • Can be incorporated seamlessly into daily life
  • Carries the least risk of injury, making it ideal for individuals with joint issues or concerns about osteoarthritis

Running

  • Delivers a higher intensity workout
  • Significantly increases calorie burn per session, leading to faster weight loss results
  • May not be suitable for everyone due to its high-impact nature, which can exacerbate joint problems

Ultimately, the choice between walking and running depends on your personal preferences and circumstances. Here are some questions to help guide your decision:

  • Do you have a history of joint issues? Running might exacerbate these problems due to the increased pressure placed on the joints during each stride. Walking could be a better option in this case.
  • Do you crave the adrenaline rush of a high-intensity workout? Perhaps running would be more satisfying and motivating for you.

Remember, consistency is key in any weight loss journey. Choosing an activity you enjoy will help maintain motivation and encourage regular workouts.

So, whether it’s running or walking, choose based on your personal preferences and circumstances for a sustainable weight loss journey.

Conclusion

A recap of our discussion brings to light that both running and walking are beneficial for weight loss. It’s clear that running, with its high-intensity, offers more calorie-burning potential in less time. On the flip side, walking provides a low-impact, sustainable approach to losing weight, which works wonders for those with joint concerns.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to the “Running vs Walking” debate for weight loss. The choice largely depends on your personal preference, current fitness level, and unique health circumstances. So, lace up your shoes and hit the road! The most important thing is to get moving and stay active in a way that suits you best.

Read More: Diet or Exercise: Which is better for losing weight?

Picture of MMC Writing Team

MMC Writing Team

An Apple a day keeps the doctor away. We hope that we can provide you with information to stay healthy.

Picture of MMC Writing Team

MMC Writing Team

An Apple a day keeps the doctor away. We hope that we can provide you with information to stay healthy.

Subscribe to our email updates
Read These Next
Elevate your self-esteem with 10 proven tips to enhance self-worth, build resilience, and foster positive relationships.
Explore the best multivitamin for kidney disease, tailored to manage CKD with key nutrients for optimal health and well-being.
Explore 5 surprising facts about fats, their impact on health, and tips for smart fat choices to enhance your well-being.